Home / , , / Creating Space to Get It Wrong: Why Psychological Safety Matters for Learning

Creating Space to Get It Wrong: Why Psychological Safety Matters for Learning

Todd Moran November-17
FacebookLinkedInPinterestTwitterEmail

From Insights to Impact | Part 3 of 5

People need opportunities to practice, make mistakes, and build confidence before the stakes are high. Here’s how learning leaders can create those conditions without sacrificing accountability.

We Expect People to Perform. But Have We Given Them Space to Practice?

Think about the moments that matter most in your organization: a manager delivering difficult feedback, a salesperson in front of a skeptical client, a new leader making a call under pressure. We expect people to handle these moments well. Yet for many of them, the first real attempt happens live, with real consequences.

That’s a lot to ask of anyone. Complex skills aren’t built by hearing about them once. They’re built through practice, and practice means allowing for some things wrong along the way. Which is where psychological safety comes in. It’s often discussed as a workplace culture initiative, but it’s just as much a condition for learning. If people don’t feel safe trying, they won’t try, and if they don’t try, they won’t improve.

Across our NovoEdTalks podcast series, learning and talent leaders tackled the topic of psychological safety in learning and development. In one such example, Elizabeth Gomez of Costa Farms described how her organization approaches creating a safe space for experimentation. “We encourage failure-based learning. So in other words, we encourage safe-to-fail environments where people can learn from their mistakes.”

Watch NovoEdTalks Podcast Episode 64, “Planting Seeds of Growth,” with Elizabeth Gomez

The framing matters. Mistakes here aren’t something employees are expected to avoid entirely. They’re an essential part of the process, and treating them that way is exactly what makes it possible to learn from them.

Psychological Safety Doesn’t Mean Lowering Expectations

It’s easy to hear “psychological safety” and assume it means going easy on people. It doesn’t. Irina Cavescu of Learnlight offered a clear—and empowering—definition:

“Psychological safety is really the belief that you can speak up, disagree, or admit you didn’t know something or don’t understand something without being punished or embarrassed for it.”

Watch NovoEdTalks Podcast Episode 114, “The Human Advantage,” with Irina Cavescu

Read closely, that definition is about how people are treated when they speak up or admit uncertainty. It doesn’t say expectations disappear, or that consequences do. Employees can feel comfortable asking a question, flagging a concern, or trying a new approach while still being fully accountable for the outcomes of their work.

Brandon Springle of Shaw Industries named the tension directly:

“How do we create the psychological safety while still holding the line on accountability to make sure people understand consequence?”

Watch NovoEdTalks Podcast Episode 104, “Leading with Care and Challenge,” with Brandon Springle

Taken together, the two perspectives reframe the question. It isn’t safety or accountability. Safety is what makes honest effort and honest learning possible, and accountability is what ensures that learning translates into standards people can meet. Strong learning environments require both.

The Real Cost of Not Feeling Safe to Get It Wrong

What happens when the balance tips the other way? When the perceived risk of a mistake outweighs the value of participating, people adjust their behavior accordingly. They stop asking questions. They stay quiet in the meeting where a concern needed addressing. They avoid admitting they need help until a small gap has become a large one.

Learnlight’s Cavescu framed the consequences:

“They will actively withhold their best thinking because the risk of getting [it] wrong feels bigger than the value of speaking.”

This moves the issue beyond individual confidence. When people withhold their best thinking, the organization loses more than a few comments in a discussion. It loses the opportunity to catch problems early, challenge assumptions, and learn from the people closest to the work. For L&D, it also means learning programs can go through the motions while the honest questions that drive real learning never get asked.

What If We Designed Psychological Safety Into the Learning Experience?

If safe practice matters, the next question is how to provide it at scale. NovoEd Chief Learning Strategist Todd Moran starts with an honest observation: One of the most effective ways to create a safe space for practice is the classic human one, working directly with a manager. The problem is that this approach doesn’t scale well. A manager can’t be a practice partner for every skill, for every person, all of the time.

So Moran asks a different design question: Can the learning itself create these moments? In the video below, he describes a progression. It might begin with something lightweight, like text-based roleplay, in a low-stakes setting where it’s safe to try things out. As people build confidence, they can move into a more demanding format, such as voice-based AI roleplay. Along the way, AI can give feedback measured against an organizational rubric or standard, so people can practice on their own time and see how their performance compares with what the organization expects. From there, peers, managers, and senior leaders can step in with human coaching.

Moran sums up the effect this way: “getting it wrong and that’s OK because it’s going to make you better.” And all of it happens before a learner has to “stand up in front of a client or engage a customer.”

Notice how each step does a different job. The early stages lower the cost of a mistake to almost nothing, which makes it easy to start. The later stages raise the realism, so the skill is tested under conditions closer to the real thing. And the organizational rubric means “better” has a definition, so safe practice stays tied to the standards people will be held to. That’s how a learning experience can protect people from embarrassment while still holding the line on accountability.

The emphasis here is on learning design, not technology. AI is one way to expand access to practice, but the larger opportunity is building environments where people can develop skills before applying them in high-stakes situations. Melanie Lepine, Global Head of Talent and e-Learning for a global real estate services firm, described the same shift: “It’s not content, it’s practice. And so it’s an actual doing experience rather than a listening experience.”

Watch NovoEdTalks Podcast Episode 95, “Learning Without Limits,” with Melanie Lepine

Building Capability Means Giving People Room to Experiment

Complex capabilities don’t develop in a straight line. People need to try different approaches, see what worked and what didn’t, and adjust, again and again, before they’re asked to perform in real, high-stakes situations. That kind of experimentation only happens when trying and falling short isn’t treated as a failure of the individual.

Costa Farms’ Gomez described a culture built around that idea: “We are admitting and rewarding unsuccessful trials.”

“Rewarding unsuccessful trials” may sound counterintuitive, but it follows from the logic of learning. If the only outcome that gets recognized is success, people will avoid anything uncertain. If effort and learning get recognized for their value, as well, people take the risks that lead to growth.

Lepine connected this to capability: “We’re trying to give people the opportunity to build that experience with psychological safety.”

The key word is experience. The goal isn’t simply to help employees feel more confident. It’s to make sure their confidence is supported by demonstrated skill, earned through repeated practice in spaces where mistakes are part of the process. Confidence without experience is fragile. Confidence built through practice holds up under pressure.

From Insights to Impact: What L&D Leaders Can Do Differently

The conversations in this article point to a handful of questions worth bringing to your next planning session:

  1. Identify high-stakes moments. Where are employees expected to perform without sufficient opportunities to practice?
  2. Create a safe space for mistakes. Are learners comfortable experimenting, asking questions, and getting things wrong?
  3. Maintain accountability. Are expectations clear, even when employees are encouraged to take risks and learn?
  4. Build progressive practice. How can learning experiences move from lower-pressure exercises to realistic workplace situations?
  5. Expand access to feedback. Where can technology, peers, and managers help employees practice and improve more consistently?

If you’re looking for a first step, start with the first question. Pick one high-stakes moment, such as a customer conversation or a difficult manager discussion, and map out what practice currently looks like before it happens. The gap you find is your starting point.

People shouldn’t have to wait until the stakes are high to find out whether they’re ready. Learning leaders have an opportunity to create environments where employees can practice, make mistakes, and develop the confidence and capability to perform when it matters.

Keep Connecting the Dots

This is the third of five conversations in the From Insights to Impact series. If this one resonated, these pieces explore closely related ideas: